Though Peiss did a phenomenal job at proving her thesis in the sense of giving a book on a specific time and topic, she failed to give the reader some real life backbone through a more personal aspect. The reader is left feeling the need of wanting more from the sources rather than from Peiss as a historian.
Though the dangers as being seen as a prostitute are not paralleled between the two different eras, the concept of men pursuing an unescorted female in such a setting remains consistent. In another similar tone, the notion Peiss points out of dance halls either lowering their fares for women or waving the fare altogether is consistent with the parallel thought of clubs often times lowering or waving cover charges for women for the simple fact of luring women into their establishments.
Peiss explains that owners of dance halls would alter their fees for women because women were usually unable to afford the fee and the owners really wanted more women, like today, to be at their establishment so the men would also come and lavish the women with drinks.
Though I could understand where Mr. McKnight is coming from as far as the history aspect is concerned, to go as far as to openly say that this piece of work should be considered a valuable source and should become a reoccurring them is a tad outlandish. As far as a concentrated topic of a forty year time span is concerned, Peiss did a phenomenal job at capturing the essence of a fairly large group of women. But the fact of the matter is that Peiss only concerned herself with a forty year window of a specific gender, of a specific class.
Moreover, it took her nearly two hundred pages to repeat her central idea several times over. Peiss created a very narrow window for the reader to look into and gave them a concentrated view of what a certain time frame looked like for a specific group of people in a certain social class.
The book was very well organized and was interesting in its topic of choice. Bib Mcknight, John C. Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Main page Cheap Amusement Book Review. It does a better job of communicating what life was like at the time. Peiss describes the class perceptions of New Yorkers at the turn of the twentieth century.
To look more closely at those on the lower end of the class scale, Peiss considered studies of income at the time. The same problems of very high urban rents and food existed then as do today, so these families had little disposable income As a result, all the family members worked, including unmarried daughters. So, these working families had little time for leisure. Even when unemployed [ Apparently, marriages were meant to be loveless affairs organized for the purposes of procreation and of having life-long live-in cleaning and childrearing services, no doubt.
So the husbands and wives both not only sought enjoyment but also were expected to seek recreation and enjoyment outside the home—separately. Generally, working men went to the saloons. Their culture of the saloon was so endemic that the saloons practically took over. Considering how many fewer people lived there at the time, those numbers are staggering!
A whole subculture developed around what happened inside those saloons. Another element of that subculture was the custom of treating. No surprise that bars and bartenders were behind the formation of these large cohort groups.
While all this fun was going on, the wives did not have so much fun. How did she even have time to conceive thirteen babies? So now, if there was any sort of recreation, the women were likely to have more work to do, such as preparing the food for the picnic or taking extra care that the children looked their most presentable for being shown off at the park.
They worked so hard having a good time [ Things became a little more economically stable here. Whether these women worked to support themselves or their families, a majority of them worked. Also, incidentally, women in domestic service had a much harder time going out at night and making their own choices in general about their leisure.
When women began to have jobs that supported the growing mercantile industry in New York, they had power in a way that they had not seen before. This demonstrates a kind of power that must have been impossible among domestic workers. But also within a certain industry, the varying cultural and ethnic traditions might predict or give certain groups of women strength to behave a certain way or prevent them from behaving another way.
Most important about all these phenomena was that the working women came to develop their own unique traditions, separate from those of their families and ethic groups. They mixed in social groups without regard for religion or ethnicity, which apparently did not happen otherwise Peiss explains that women could think about themselves in terms of sex and find out about sex. The ability to know and understand sex gave them power that they could not have known before. So what an amazingly powerful experience it was for these young women to work and on the sly to talk about what it meant to have sex.
And work started early. Even so, these young people found time for socializing in a way that their parents never had. Social clubs began to be the rage, and dressing up became a point of pride. Romance was difficult for these young working people, most of whom either lived in tenements with their families or in single-sex boarding houses that were chaperoned. The freedom to date went along with cultural tensions in immigrant families, between the new world liberalism and the old world conservatism.
The biggest fad of all for single working women was dancing.
Amusement came in a variety of forms such as: social clubs, dances, variety shows, amusement parks, cheap theatre, nickel dumps, and even standing on the street corner. The businessman's goal was to make a profit off of these activities.
An essay or paper on Role of Cheap Amusements. An extremely interesting, but ever-contradictory sociological study of sexual relationsis presented in the Kathy Peiss book Cheap Amusements. The reason I say that it is ever-contradictory is that the arguments are presented for both the benefit of cheap amusements for a woman s place in societ.
Peiss, Kathy. (). Cheap Amusements. New York: Temple University. In Cheap Amusements, Kathy Peiss studies the customs, values, public styles, and ritualized interactions expressed in leisure time of the working-class women living in New York. Cheap Amusements Essay Peiss’s book, Cheap Amusements, was about women’s roles at the turn of the century in New York. Her main idea was that working women at the turn of the century were trying to create more leisure time and autonomy despite the stereotypes that came with some of this newfound independence.
Cheap amusements became a real problem especially for the women of the late nineteenth century. The amusements were blamed for debasing womanly virtues, segregating youth from family and fostering a dangerously expressive culture. Cheap amusements essays out of 10 based on 15 ratings. 10 (Letters , Indexes) . mohawk college resume help homework help software "The anthology presents custom writing service number a highly engaging sample of cheap amusements essays divergent viewpoints.